Town Hall
What the Midterms Could Mean for Israel
About This Video
On October 28, 2026, the day after Israel voted and six days before the US midterms, the Atlanta Israel Coalition asked what the midterms could mean for Israel. Joel Rayburn, former US Special Envoy for Syria and a senior fellow at the Hudson Institute, talks with Uri Zehavi about the next US aid agreement with Israel, what Congress can and can't do on Iran, campus antisemitism, younger voters, Qatar, Syria after Assad, Saudi normalization, Turkey, and why he thinks the US-Israel tech alliance will matter even more than the military one.
Joel Rubin, former Deputy Assistant Secretary of State in the Obama administration, was meant to join him. A technical problem with Microsoft Teams kept him out, so Joel Rayburn took the whole hour on his own. We'll have Rubin back for a conversation of his own.
AIC does not endorse or oppose any candidate or party. Our guests speak for themselves.
Transcript
These are the captions from the video, made by machine with the names checked, so a word may still be off. We added who is speaking. Tap a time to play from there.
0:00Welcome from Uri Zehavi
Uri Zehavi0:03
Good evening, everybody. Thank you for coming. I'm Uri Zehavi. I'm a director at the Atlanta Israel Coalition and was meant to be moderating tonight. But I think we'll just be in conversation. Israel voted yesterday and they're still counting. Americans vote on Tuesday. So, I mean, there's really no better week to ask what the midterms could mean for Israel. If you're following the count, they're on the double envelopes now. That's the soldiers and everybody else who voted from home, well over 400,000 ballots. It runs until tomorrow evening Israel time and the official results are due next week. If you're new to us, the Atlanta Israel Coalition is a grassroots group.
We educate, mobilize, and unite people in support of Israel and against antisemitism. We've run more than 230 programs since 2018. And since October 7th, we've been to Israel on five aid missions. They're nonpartisan, which is why you were meant to get both a Democrat and a Republican tonight. A couple of quick things before we start. AIC does not endorse or oppose any candidate or party and our guests speak for themselves. Tonight's about policy. So we won't be getting into particular races or candidates. And both of our guests were meant to get the same questions at the same time. Your questions can be placed in the Q&A chat. There's a Q&A button at the top of your screen.
Send them whenever they come up and we'll get to as many as we can just now after eight. And one small ask. AIC runs on its members. It starts from $9 a month. And it's what keeps evening like this for free. You'll find it at AtlantaIsrael.org. Now, with me tonight is Joel Rayburn, who spent 26 years as an army officer, ended up at the National Security Council covering Iran, Iraq, Syria, and Lebanon, and then served as a US Special Envoy for Syria in President Trump's first term. He's a senior fellow at the Hudson Institute now. He also taught history at West Point. So we'll see how this goes.
2:14What's at Stake for Israel in These Midterms
Uri Zehavi2:15
Joel, you were the senior director for Iran, Iraq, Syria, and Lebanon at the National Security Council. What's the single biggest thing at stake for Israel in this election, whichever way it goes?
Joel Rayburn2:27
Very, very good to be with you and with your audience. I think we're in a phase where it's – and it's not just this election, but it's something that's been coming where the question of Israel and US policy and the US-Israel relationship, you know, for decades, really since the beginning of that relationship between the United States and Israel, the alliance, it's been a bipartisan matter. In fact, it really didn't matter what party was in power, what party was in power in the White House, what party was in power in Congress. The relationship was stable, reliable, that there would be US support for Israel and vice versa in mutual foreign policy issues.
Of course, there were disputes from time to time, but generally there was something close to a consensus in Washington, D.C. about the place of Israel in US foreign policy. But that's now in question. It's in question for a variety of reasons coming – there's some questioning of Israel's role in US foreign policy coming from several different directions, which we can talk about. But Basically, we're in a window and this election in particular, this midterm election, is going to determine whether Israel is going to continue to be a national bipartisan issue in US foreign policy and politics or whether it's going to become a partisan issue.
It's been migrating more and more in recent years toward being a partisan issue. And I would say since October 7th, it's really run almost full speed toward partisanship, where the question of the US-Israel relationship has almost become a litmus test. And that's certainly true. I think if our friend Joel Rubin were able to sign on, I think he would probably – we could talk about the place that this question has occupied on the Democratic side. But certainly on the Republican side too, there seems to be a growing questioning. I wouldn't say it's not anywhere near a majority. It's not near a plurality of people who count themselves sort of on the conservative side, on the right side in US politics.
But it seems to be growing for a variety of reasons. So I think that's what's at stake in this election is whether Israel is going to continue to be as it traditionally has been a bipartisan foreign policy issue for the United States or a partisan one. On the US side, that's what the midterms, I think, that's the most important aspect for it in these midterms.
5:19The Next US Aid Agreement with Israel
Uri Zehavi5:20
The 10-year US aid agreement with Israel, the MOU, runs out in 2028. So whoever is in the next Congress ends up writing the next one. In a sentence, what does your party want to keep in it? And then, really, what's up for grabs with this?
Joel Rayburn5:38
This is a hard question to answer in a sentence, but I think the nature of the MOU has been changing, just as the US-Israel relationship has been changing. It's no longer really a question of assistance. It's no longer a question of a donor country to sort of a client, sort of a receiver, recipient of security aid. It's the relationship, the military to military security relationship has been growing toward a partnership. So I think the next MOU is going to encapsulate that. It's going to involve technology sharing and intelligence sharing and so on, much more than it has been in the past, where it's been sort of US financing of Israeli arms acquisition.
6:35The America First Argument for Less Aid
Uri Zehavi6:36
Excuse me. There's a loud America first argument on the right that Israel should get less from the US, even with everything it gets in return. How worried should pro-Israel voters be about the floor in the party?
Joel Rayburn6:49
Yeah, this is a question of concern. And you're absolutely right and that the US expenditure on foreign military financing in particular for Israel has come under a lot of scrutiny since October 7th and during the Trump administration on the right. And so this is – yes, I think observers need to be concerned about this, but that's also why I think we can't really – for those of us who really want to see American interests first, American interests foremost, you've got to explain why a relationship with Israel supports American objectives, supports American national security objectives. That there's value from the US-Israel alliance. I mean it kind of – for me, somebody like me who was in the military and national security for 30 years, it almost goes without saying, but I mean I've seen it firsthand over my career.
It's a given. But there's a new generation of people in the electorate and who are active, and for them it's not a given. They need to be shown the math on why the relationship with Israel benefits the United States in terms of our – not just our military interests, but our technological interests, our economic partnership. You know, Israel is a startup nation and innovator in a variety of different sectors. You know, that needs to be explained how – what Israel brings to the table that benefits the United States. I mean in my opinion, the United States gets more out – we get more out of it than we put in.
But that's got to be explained to people. And I don't think necessarily – as I say, those of us who are supporters of that relationship have taken it for granted and haven't shown the homework in the past.
8:49Conditions on Aid
Uri Zehavi8:50
conditions on US aid to Israel, is there a version that you could live with and, you know, where is the line there?
Joel Rayburn9:02
Look, there are always conditions on aid to any security assistance partner for the United States. That's built into law. There are certain things that end users of US military equipment and technology have to abide by or else that – or else it's suspended. The relationship is suspended. So, I mean, there should be enforcement of those things within reason and not according to a – you wouldn't want it to be done according to a double standard. But we need to – all the recipients of US security assistance and US arms sales and so on need to – US needs to ensure that they're abiding by the conditions in law for that security assistance. That comes up not just with Israel but with a variety of partners. So I think there are already conditions in there that we're living with.
I don't see a need to – I mean, personally, I think we would get into problematic territory if we start to put another layer of conditions, political conditions on aid beyond that, to sort of responding to, you know, the news of the day and the flavor of the day. You think that battle is coming, though? That contest is coming. That debate is coming in the next Congress, especially if the House were to change hands. I think you would see a legislative agenda that would bring that question right out as a – probably as a matter of priority in the next Congress. And then you'd see a debate over whether the Congress is going to add its own conditions and how far those would go.
10:42Does It Matter Which Party Holds Congress?
Uri Zehavi10:43
Speaking of Congress and its composition, for Israel, does it really matter which party holds the House or the Senate? Or is it really about which members are on which committees?
Joel Rayburn10:52
Yeah, I think it will – I mean, my personal opinion is that right now in this sort of charged atmosphere that we're in, that it will – it could make a qualitative difference. I think the current Congress is probably more disposed to support, is going to be less skeptical of the US-Israel relationship than maybe the next one will be, depending on the outcome of the midterms. Right now, sitting right here, we don't really know – we're just a few days away. We don't know, for example, which way the Senate is going to go. I think the conventional wisdom is that the House, there's a strong possibility that it could change hands.
And so the committees that oversee the different aspects of the US-Israel relationship in the House will change hands. And yes, those committees could bring different aspects to the relationship under more scrutiny, especially the military-to-military relationship and probably the intelligence-sharing relationship.
12:04Iran: What Congress Gets a Say In
Uri Zehavi12:05
Speaking of intelligence, let's move over briefly to the war with Iran. There's been reporting this week that Washington is telling the Gulf to expect a short campaign against Iran after the midterms. Setting the White House aside for a moment, on Iran, what does Congress actually get a say in here? War powers, sanctions, money, and does any of that change if the House or Senate were to flip?
Joel Rayburn12:33
So I don't – I mean the President's Article II authorities to conduct foreign policy and prosecute war are so extensive once he's been elected and once he's been granted those authorities by Congress, which he has under our – in the current arrangement, that I wouldn't anticipate a significant change in the conduct of the campaign between – probably for some months. I think where it would run into a change if one or both in the Houses of Congress were to change hands, when it comes time for the annual debate over the defense budget, and then – and probably over the intelligence budget, but certainly over the defense budget.
I think then you would see – you would see – it would start to have an effect if the House is in different hands than the White House at that point. Because then the House controls the purse strings. So if a president wants to continue to fund operations, then he's going to have to – there's only so far that he's going to be able to go without authorization from Congress at that point. And it could boil down to continuing resolutions or something, or there could be a real – there could be a real standoff. There could be a real showdown over the Pentagon's budget bill. Probably the latest that it could go is probably, say, you know, the late fall of 2027 on that budget contest. But in the normal cycle of things, you see the Pentagon's budget come up for debate and beginning to shape it between the executive branch and the House and Senate, too, afterward, along about the May timeframe.
And so I think that's – look for that as when the showdown would probably begin. But then you could have, say – you could have, you know, five months of a faceoff between the Houses of Congress or between Congress and the White House over the money.
15:02If Israel Has to Strike Iran's Nuclear Program Again
Uri Zehavi15:02
So if Israel decides it has to go after Iran's nuclear program again, what does it need from Congress, and would it get it?
Joel Rayburn15:15
I don't think – I mean operational choices like that between now and, you know, let's say the midterm – the medium term. The immediate term, I think it's sort of baked in. The Pentagon and no doubt – and I think in the US-Israel relationship, let's say munitions, deliveries, and so on, that's sort of – you have what you have. So – and Congress is not going to affect that, I think, immediately. Now, if – you could have – Congress can vote to defund a military operation. I mean that's essentially what Congress did to President Reagan vis-à-vis Nicaragua and the support to the Contras in the mid-1980s.
And if that were to happen, I mean either – then a president has to veto that defunding legislation or has to try to figure out some sort of alternative arrangement. And when the Reagan administration did that, they got into real trouble. So there's only so far that you can stretch the boundaries there of what you can do in terms of resourcing a campaign. But I don't expect that that kind of – I think that would be unlikely for Congress to be able to – for Congress to do that in the near term after the new Congress is seated in January. So I don't think that there's going to be a really immediate operational impact on what either Israel or the United States military are doing.
16:56Pro-Israel Voters Who Feel Pushed Out
Uri Zehavi16:57
So, Joel, you are here tonight or meant to be as the Republican voice, and you served in President Trump's first administration. Where would you say the Republican Party is getting it wrong with pro-Israel voters who feel pushed out, and what might it take to win them back?
Joel Rayburn17:15
It's a good question. I don't know. I don't think the Republican Party feels to me like – I mean on the partisan spectrum, and I would be interested either tonight if it happens or at some later day in hearing Joel Rubin's take on this. I was really looking forward to it as well because he's – he knows that – he knows the scene inside his party very well having been – he's a veteran of successive administrations in the Hill on the Democratic side. So I don't want to try to – I won't try to speak for that side. It does feel like on the – among a pro-Israel constituency in the United States that the Republican Party has become more in alignment – or I would say that that constituency has become more in alignment with the Republican Party than the Democratic Party in recent years.
And I think that's not really good for an important alliance that the United States has. I mean it's good that – I think the majority of the Republican Party, and we can see this even in the opinion polls that come out, you still see a strong majority of Republicans think that the alliance with Israel is important and needs to be maintained, and they remain largely pro-Israel, certainly anti-Iran. So I'm not that worried I'm not that worried yet about that.
18:45Campus Antisemitism
Uri Zehavi18:46
let's switch gears and talk maybe a little bit about campus and antisemitism. So we're based in Atlanta, campuses close to home for many of us. Congress has held hearings, and there's been a very visible fight over federal money, especially with Columbia and Harvard. Has any of that made it better for a Jewish student on a college campus, and what would?
Joel Rayburn19:12
That's a good question. And without being in the shoes of a Jewish student, that's a hard one to answer. I hope the answer is yes. It feels like Jewish students went without top cover from the federal government for quite some time as the conditions for Jewish students deteriorated and began to deteriorate visibly on some campuses, very unfortunately. So it does feel like in the last few years there's been top cover, at least for me as an outside observer to that relationship, it does feel like there's top cover now from the government, that the government has been more adamant. Congress has been more adamant in saying, "Jewish students, we have your back," you know, the kind of harassment, pressure, and vilification that you're suffering on some campuses is not acceptable, and it's illegal in many cases, the way that it's playing out, and that Jewish students have to be accorded those protections, just as we would hope that any minority would be accorded those kind of protections.
Or just any student of any kind, whether they're a minority or not, needs to be accorded protections. So it feels like there's been a rebound, if you will, over the last three years or so, in that regard.
20:50Title VI and the Antisemitism Awareness Act
Uri Zehavi20:50
So there's quite a bit of public debate over, say, Title VI of the Civil Rights Act and whether or not it's actually doing its job for Jewish students. Or, you know, does Congress need to write something new? Or the Antisemitism Awareness Act. Do you think there's any appetite in the next Congress to take that on, and should they?
Joel Rayburn21:14
That's going to be—that's a good question. I think it'll depend on the composition of Congress. I think there are some—what's at stake right now, there are some, I think, figures who are running for Congress who, as I described it, are skeptical of the US-Israel relationship. And unfortunately, I think for some people, that carries over into relations with and attitudes toward the American Jewish communities here. And in a way that is really, I think, very unfortunate. So if that happens, then, you know, you could have some tension in the Congress. You get it. You can see it coming out from time to time in Congress over the last couple of years.
But it's been on the fringe. So I think this is—we just have to wait and see what the outcome of the elections are and whether that fringe becomes more sizable and begins to weigh in on the legislative agenda. I hope that's not the case. But also, I don't—you know, I think Republicans tend to be—and I don't want to say that this isn't true of Democrats either. I think Republicans tend to, I think, tend to favor the enforcement of existing law as opposed to the creation of new law to solve problems that existing law could solve if it were enforced. So, I mean, a lot of the abuses that we've seen on college campuses are already prohibited by law.
So if there's just an emphasis on law enforcement, and that has to come from the executive branch and from local governments, then, you know, hopefully there wouldn't be a need for new legislation. If there are loopholes, though, if there are—and there may be, for example, if there's some sort of—if there are loopholes that allow for the financing of campaigns that are intended to target and harass Jewish students or any minority, then those loopholes need to be looked at through a legislative agenda.
23:35Younger Voters and Social Media
Uri Zehavi23:35
The polling has younger voters in both parties cooler on Israel than their parents. And what are we going to see in 10, 20 years in terms of bipartisan support for Israel and where it actually stands? And is that—and where people are getting their news, particularly young people on Israel from social media and things like that, is that something Congress should touch or just stay entirely out of?
Joel Rayburn24:06
Well, I think—look, the question, what—10 to 20 years, that will depend on—I mean, For the last few years, there's been a mounting tide of sentiment that's been targeted and disinformation, I think, misinformation, most of it, that's been targeting young people and trying to shape their attitudes. I wouldn't say this is just a spontaneous phenomenon that's been happening. There's also been concerted—propaganda campaigns have been a concerted influence operation going on to try to shake the US-Israel relationship and to shape youth attitudes toward it, younger people's attitudes toward it. On the other side, there has not been a commensurate effort to explain the value, as I mentioned before, in the US-Israel relationship.
So I think, really, where will we be in the attitudes toward the US-Israel relationship 10 years from now, 15, 20 years from now? I think it depends on how well, how energetically the people who support that relationship explain and defend it between now and then and do something commensurate to try to inform young Americans about the nature of the relationship, the value of the relationship. You have to be honest about sometimes the drawbacks, and there have been drawbacks from time to time. There are things, you know, the United States and Israel are not the same country, so occasionally they do have disagreements over policy, but are generally, you know, have been oriented in the same direction almost since Israel's foundation. Maybe there was a small window there where Israel was a little more aligned with Moscow, but they got over that pretty quickly.
And so I think they're really, it's incumbent on supporters in the relationship to get in there and mix it up and be able to fight in the, to compete in the marketplace of ideas between now and then.
26:29Israel's Election, Seen from Washington
Uri Zehavi26:29
Israel voted yesterday. It's still counting, as we mentioned at the top of the program, whoever ends up forming the government. Does anything change in how Washington deals with Jerusalem or does Congress mostly not care who the prime minister is, regardless of what, you know, the headlines might say?
Uri Zehavi26:49
sorry. And if Israel takes weeks to form a government, which seems like might be on the earlier part of that timeline, does that actually cost anything in Washington?
Joel Rayburn27:01
It's a good question. I mean, Prime Minister Netanyahu has been such a towering figure, not just in Israeli politics, but in his relationship with the United States that, yeah, it will make a qualitative difference somehow. If there's, if there's, if there's a change of leadership in Israel, I don't know how likely that is right now. But regardless, the, it, technically it's not going to change much because the, the US foreign policy toward Israel is, is that that's a state to state relationship. Certainly if you personalities can enter into it, but on the whole, the institutional relationship is going to, is going to continue regardless of who's in office on either side of the relationship.
I don't think, I don't think Congress is going to have to deal with Israel regardless in, in, in, in roughly the same way, regardless of whether there's a continuity or change in leadership in Jerusalem and vice versa. So I, I, I, I'm one, I don't expect things to fundamentally change. Uh, in, in the immediate term.
Uri Zehavi28:15
Um, I'll just remind everyone if they have questions, they can put them in the Q and a chat and we'll get to audience questions in a moment. Um, all y'all are sending those in, um, um, just wrap up a little bit with,
28:30Bipartisan Support Come January
Uri Zehavi28:30
so do you think that, um, come January is bipartisan support for Israel stronger or weaker than it is today?
Joel Rayburn28:43
Look, it, bipartisan support for Israel has been on a downward slope over the last few years. And so I, I, I, for one would like to see that arrested. I don't know that in, in, in, it'll depend on the composition of the new Congress. It will depend on what's happening strategically as well. Uh, it will depend on, um, it will depend on whether, is, is, is the war escalating? Is the war deescalating? Is the war resolved? The war with the Iranian regime. I mean, um, which has been, which has sort of exacerbated, um, this, this, this same trend. So it's, it's tough to predict. I think generally speaking, um, bipartisan support for the US Israel relationship has been under a lot of pressure and it's, it's, it's been under increasing pressure over time.
Uh, as, as, as I mentioned, so I, I don't, you know, the, the pushback has not yet happened. The, the turning around of that trend has, has not yet happened. Um, so, so, so, oh, you know, the, if you just follow the trend lines, um, you, you have to be somewhat concerned, I think, over how things are going to look over time.
29:59What America Gets for $4 Billion a Year
Uri Zehavi29:59
Right. Um, people hear nearly $4 billion a year in US aid to Israel and think it's charity. Um, you touched on earlier that you wish people would understand a little bit more of what that might encompass. So to someone that isn't familiar with what's actually going on and what, you know, aid means in this sense, what does America actually get for that?
Joel Rayburn30:23
Well, look, essentially, I mean, most of that is, is the United States helping Israel to buy US military equipment, US arms and, and, and other military equipment. So it's actually, I mean, it's a bit circular. The expenditure is, is, is, is a bit circular. It's not like the United States just sort of writing Israel a check for a stipend and then Israel goes off and does what it wants with it. This is foreign. It's mostly foreign military financing, um, which can only be, it's, it's, it's like, it's like giving Israel, you know, if you go to Chuck E. Cheese and you get the Chuck E. Cheese tokens, you can only spend them on things in the Chuck E. Cheese shop.
You can't, uh, so it's like giving, it's like giving Israel tokens to come back and buy only in the American, the American shop. So it's, it's, it's, uh, it's not, it's, it's, it's not a straight out, uh, gift of $4 billion. So the US US defense industry that benefits us on, it benefits the US military because the, the more business, the more, the, the more sales that the US defense industry has, it means they can keep production lines going. A lot of times if, if, if, if in the United States military, we don't have a big order for munitions. Munitions or other equipment or, or, or what have systems from our own defense industry, sometimes in lean budget years, but we want to keep those production lines going.
So that, that during those kinds of times, it's always good for us to have allies purchasing from our, from our defense industry. Uh, not only that it, it, it, it, it benefits us because then there's, we, we have, we have some other forces that are not ours, but that are allied with us. Then in a time of, of conflict or deterrence are, are interoperable with ours. And so, because we're using the same equipment, we, which means, and we, if you have the same equipment, it means you usually are using similar doctrine. And you're training very similarly on those weapons systems or the, or those other military, uh, operational systems.
So that's, that's all to the good. That's why, that's why foreign military sales benefits the United States. Beyond that, strategically speaking, if the Israeli, if the Israeli, if the Israeli military is highly capable, it's, and it's almost like a forward deployed ally of ours in a critical region, then that reduces the burden on the United States to look out for alliance interests there, uh, directly. Um, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, to, to, to protect our shared security interests that would cost the United States a lot more if we had to do it alone. And then, in, in, in, in, in, in, uh, more recently, um, the Israeli military capabilities have provided, uh, some very, very timely and crucial, uh, uh, uh, defense capabilities to other critical partners in the United States in that region.
So the, are the, are the Gulf States in Jordan, for example, in, in, in, in particular, uh, so, so I would say, uh, those are the benefits I've, I've started talking now and forgotten what the original question was, but I hope, I hope I got around to an answer to it. I think your question was, your question was the 4 billion. What, what do we get out of it? I mean, so the, so those are the major things that we get out of it.
Uri Zehavi33:55
I think just, so on a, on a strictly, on, I would say on a, just according to a strict America first, uh, analysis. Yeah. So in essence, it's a jobs program for the United States and it saves the United States military from putting itself in harm's way in many cases.
Joel Rayburn34:14
I think, yeah, that, okay. That's a bit of an oversimplification, but, uh, but it's, I think it's, it's in that direction. Yes. It's not so much that it's a jobs program. It's almost like it's a capabilities program. And again, if, if we have, let's say in a given year, if the Pentagon is only going to buy X hundred of a certain munition, then the defense industry might, might, uh, contract to just have the, the production lines going to deliver that. But then if, if, if, if Israel is going to purchase another X hundred, why that keeps the capacity, um, uh, you know, we, it keeps the capacity greater.
And then if the United States then wants to ramp up as we're doing now with, for example, of air defense interceptors and other, uh, uh, other key munitions, uh, then we, then we're glad of those years, those leaner years where our allies, uh, were the, were the, were the people putting in the orders.
35:15Audience Questions: Is Iran Closer to a Nuclear Weapon?
Uri Zehavi35:15
Um, and now we have our growing list of audience questions. We'll try to get to what time allows. Um, Plain question: is Iran closer to a nuclear weapon today than it was two years ago or further away.
Joel Rayburn35:32
Further away. There's been a real evisceration of their physical capability, the physical, um, the, the physical program. Uh, I mean, the, the, the enriched, uh, uranium material is almost inaccessible to them, you know, buried under a mountain. A lot of their technology has been destroyed and is under mountains, under, under rubble, very difficult for them to reconstitute. And I think we have a lot of, uh, and there's a deterrent against them doing it now. So they're much further away. They still have the human capital. They still have the plans and the know-how. So it's, it's, it's going to be a danger as long as there's a regime there, uh, that wants to get a nuclear weapon.
Uh, we can, we can only really be safe, uh, from, uh, their nuclear ambitions. Uh, if, if the regime, uh, if there's, if there's, there's a different kind of government or, uh, or the current government undertakes a radical change or capitulates and, and, and just abandons the, those ambitions. But materially speaking, they're further away.
36:44Gaza After the War, and Congress
Uri Zehavi36:44
on Gaza after the war and the hostage deal and the, uh, board of peace, et cetera, does Congress have any real say in what happens next or is it all the white house?
Joel Rayburn36:58
Uh, that depends on the timeframe. If it's the immediate term, you know, the, the executive branch, the white house is going to be managing the immediate term. But as I mentioned, if it gets into, if it's a little further down the road and you get to the point where let's say, um, US policy vis-a-vis Gaza, um, is going to require more resourcing or more legal authorities or someone, then Congress is going to get involved because Congress is going to have to approve the budget for that. And, or they're going to have to approve the, the authorizations for that to make, uh, to make whatever it is lawful.
Or if there are new organizations that have to be created, Congress is going to have a, uh, is going to have a say in that, but that's a little further down the road.
37:40Qatar
Uri Zehavi37:40
Um, I have a couple of questions on the same topics. I'll try to merge them a little bit here. Um, but we were talking about, uh, Israel is almost a sort of forward deployed force for the US, um, within the region, Qatar hosts America's biggest air base. Um, but it also hosts Hamas's political leadership. How does Washington live with both? And should it?
Joel Rayburn38:06
Yeah. Yeah. I think this is, this is a delicate question, but I, I, I think, um, in my own observation, having been, um, in, in national security roles, sometimes it's just a fly on the wall, uh, going back some ways over successive administrations that, uh, um, I think in the past, uh, Qatar occasionally had, Qatar had policies that, um, that I, I think were problematic. Um, but on the other hand, there were successive US administrations that found it, um, useful, uh, to have Qatar, not just Qatar, but some others, but the, but Qatar to play an intermediary role. So, uh, uh, on, uh, on, on, on some occasions, the countries were doing what, uh, US administration, uh, enlisted them to do, for example, opening up an office for the Taliban in Doha.
They did that at the request of, of the US administration. Uh, some aspects, I think of the, of the hosting of Hamas, uh, fall into that category as well.
Uri Zehavi39:17
Um, um, Qatar shares the world's largest gas field with Iran. How much would you say that that shapes what Doha will or won't do on Iran?
Joel Rayburn39:26
I think all the Gulf States, um, all, all the Gulf States have to, uh, have to be careful for all the Gulf States, the Iranian regime has become a threat. And for all the Gulf States, the Iranian regime has become, I think what they would privately describe as an existential threat. I do believe the way in which the Iranian regime, when, when the current war began at the end of February, beginning of March, and the first thing that the Iranian regime did, uh, in response to, you know, the, the US Israeli military pressure was to lash out at the Gulf countries, all of which were trying to stay neutral at that time.
I think that the lesson that the Gulf countries took away from that was that they cannot live alongside that regime as it's currently constituted, uh, uh, in safety. They can't, they, they, it, it, it, it's sort of like their, their attitude, I think is we can't live with these guys over the longer term. Now, um, in the immediate term, they are there. They do have to live with their right across the water. They've, but, uh, but I think in the, in the longer term there, because there was an idea, you remember leading up to, uh, this war. Remember, for example, in Beijing, the, the, the, the, the Chinese supposedly were brokering a different kind of relationship between Iran and Saudi Arabia.
And there were all kinds of ideas like that, that the Gulf and South and the Iranians were going to come to some new sort of rapprochement or non-aggression pact, if you will. But that all flew out the window and it flew out the window because of what the Iranians chose to do. They chose to punish the Gulf for something the Gulf wasn't involved in. Um, and including Qatar, including striking Qatar.
Uri Zehavi41:24
Uh, last question with Qatar here. Um, they put billions into American universities and it owns Al Jazeera. Putting those together, how much has Qatari money shaped how young Americans see Israel and what, if anything, should Congress do about it?
Joel Rayburn41:41
Yeah, that's a good question, but I, I, I think you have to zoom out, not just Qatar, not just whatever would, would be the problematic, um, uh, problematic aspects of that coming from Qatar, but coming from, uh, any foreign element that's, that's, uh, engaged in, in, in shaping, uh, the American education system. Um, uh, so Chinese, the Confucius centers, for example, uh, that, you know, that's something I think that the United, the US has let, uh, has had to laissez-faire an attitude about. So, so that, so that, that's changing.
42:21Syria and the Golan
Uri Zehavi42:21
Joel Rayburn, you were America's envoy for Syria. Israel now has troops on the Syrian side of the Golan and a new government in Damascus. Is that a threat to Israel or an opening?
Joel Rayburn42:35
Uh, it's, uh, well, that's, that's the question today. I have to think that, uh, I have to think that there's room there for a different, I hope so, a different relationship between Israel and Syria. And then, that, that you would not, you don't fall back into the same kind of hostility that was there under the Assad regime for 50 something years. Um, so I, I, for, I, for one would not like to see an opportunity if there is an opportunity there for a different kind of relationship. And I kind of think there is, um, I would be, it would be disappointing to see that, uh, that opportunity pass.
Uh, there are, there are problems in it, you know, and, and, and I think both sides are, are sort of figuring out how to, uh, how to exist adjacent to one another. Uh, and, and that's a tough thing, but I, I, I really do think, I, I think that has to be, the differences I, I hope can be solved politically.
43:39Saudi-Israel Normalization
Uri Zehavi43:41
excuse me, is a Saudi-Israel normalization deal still alive? And what would it take from Israel, from Riyadh, from Congress to get it done?
Joel Rayburn43:51
It's a, it's a good question. It's, it's hard to see it happening right now in the middle of the, of, of the conflict. And, um, and, um, and I also think, um, you know, the, the, there's, there's, there's been a, there's been a gap between the two sides, um, over the question of, uh, over the question of the, uh, of the Palestinians. And so there, I, I, I don't know how much room, uh, how much room there is for, for normalization right now. So I, and I, and now, if it were to, if it were to come, I mean, so I, I don't know, I don't have any inside information for you, uh, on this.
But the, the kind of aspects that we read about that are, that are reported, uh, of, of what the US would do for both sides, the Saudis and the Israelis, to try to, try to sweeten the, the, the deal and make it happen, that there probably would be a congressional role in that. And especially, you would, you would hope that you would get bipartisan support, that if it came to the point where Israel and Saudi Arabia were ready, uh, to do a normalization agreement, but what each side required was something from the United States and that there needed to be, uh, an extended commitment, sustained commitment by the United States to that, to that pact.
I, I, I hope then that you could muster a bipartisan majority, uh, super majority in Congress so that, so that, uh, um, so that any president who's helping to oversee that, helping to, to bring it about, um, could, could have it, um, done on a treaty basis, on a sustainable basis, so that it's not just something that would be, you know, undone or done and undone and redone and so on from one administration to another, which is what, you know, our, our Middle Eastern partners and allies, is always complaining about, is that the, is that the, the US political cycle means the policy changes every two to four years, sorry, and we have to say, sorry, guilty as charged on that.
45:54Turkey and Israel
Uri Zehavi45:55
Turkey is building up its presence there. How worried should Israel be about Erdogan and does Washington have Israel's back, uh, when and if the two collide?
Joel Rayburn46:05
This is, in, in, in my view, it, uh, one of the, the, the United States has a very strong and, and indispensable alliance with Israel and a strong and indispensable alliance with Turkey. Turkey is an important NATO ally and that's not going to change. Israel is an absolutely vital ally and that's not, not going to change. So it's incumbent on the United States. If, if there is, if there is a burgeoning tension between these two crucial allies of ours, then it's incumbent on the United States, uh, to try to sort that out and to, and to, to, to, to, uh, to, to, to get those sides, uh, back at least to a point where they don't view each other, uh, as a, as a threat and aren't acting in, in that, uh, in that direction.
And really it's so, I, I find it's so sad and disappointing because the Israel and Turkey, um, going back, you know, 15, 17 years ago, we're in a completely different kind of relationship. Um, and honestly, it's, it'd be much better for both sides if they could be, if they could, uh, return back to the way things were. I know that's difficult. I know that's politically difficult. Um, but I think, you know, the, the United States, that needs to be, uh, a major objective of US policy in the region, in my view.
47:33Organized Money Behind Hostile Candidates
one of the last questions here, an audience member writes in that candidates openly hostile to Israel and sometimes explicitly to Jews are getting organized money and voter registration drives behind them while the big Jewish organizations seem quiet. Without getting to any one race, um, why is that and what does effective pushback like, look like, but, you know, part of the answer we know is the law. So groups like AJC, ADL, um, et cetera, mostly 501c3 organizations like AIC, and we and they are barred from endorsing or opposing candidates, um, though we can all speak to these issues.
Joel Rayburn48:17
Yeah, I, I, I don't know the answer to that question. Um, it's, um, it, it, it's a little beyond my, beyond my expertise. He's, I think, though, um, you, it's, whether, whether money is, uh, whether the money is legal or illegal, uh, I do think there, that if, if there's, whether there's a legal cost to it or not, uh, for, uh, supportive candidates who are, uh, who are, let's say radical, have radical views, vis-a-vis, vis-a-vis, vis-a-vis, vis-a-vis, vis-a-vis, vis-a-vis our, our, um, you know, vital, uh, alliance with, with, with Israel. I think there, there should be a political cost to that. And, and so, so I hope those, those of us who, uh, those of us who support the US-Israel relationship, again, this gets back to, we, we need to make the argument.
And we need to make it, I, I think we need to make antisemitism a politically untenable position in the United States. Uh, this is, this is something that it's, that all of us need to, need to work on. All of us who are sort of, I, you know, I, I, I count myself in the mainstream there. I think all of us who are on the mainstream on this, on this question, uh, need to do the work to make it politically untenable to hold those views and to espouse that as a political agenda or an electoral agenda in the United States.
49:44Advice for Anyone Heading into Foreign Policy
Uri Zehavi49:44
Thank you. If you were advising a young Jewish American or just anyone who wants to work on foreign policy in Washington today, what would you tell them?
Joel Rayburn49:56
Uh, study history. I'm an historian. So I, I think, I think the first thing is you, you, you need to know what's gone before. You need to have the context. Uh, I can, I can see, I can recommend a, a program of study because I do that from time to time myself is put my, set myself a program of study. Um, one of the things that I've, I've done recently, uh, because, uh, you, you know, the US military was sort of in a war on terror mode for a long, long time and probably past its expiration date, um, as, um, because what was coming at us was, um, what we call great power competition. But not just that, it was great power competition that was veering back into sort of a Cold War territory. So I set myself a program of, of, of study in recent years of going back and relook, reacquainting myself with the history and, um, um, both the foreign policy and the domestic politics of the Cold War period, sort of the height of the Cold War in, uh, the Johnson administration. From Johnson administration, the Nixon administration, onto the Ford-Carter, uh, administrations. I think when, once you get to the Reagan administration, that history is more familiar, I think, to, to many of us.
But I went back and refreshed myself on the 60s and 70s, and I found that so many of the foreign policy questions were the same. So I, what I can recommend to people is, is to, is, uh, to look at histories of that period, especially covering foreign policy of the, of the Cold War, uh, of the Cold War period. I can, I can, I can recommend Robert Caro's, uh, uh, uh, histories of the Johnson, uh, of President Johnson, uh, his career and his administration. I can recommend, uh, the memoirs of Henry Kissinger, uh, Richard Nixon, and Zbigniew Brzezinski. Uh, I can recommend, uh, I can recommend some, some of the histories from the 19th, uh, of the, that, that period.
Um, uh, and, and I think the, what you'll, uh, what you wind up with is, it's almost like it's the source code, uh, for the great power competition playing out in very, in different regions of, of, of the world, uh, today. I found it, I found it, I, I found it very valuable in, in helping me to sort out, uh, the dynamics that we're trying to interpret now, uh, among, among the great powers.
52:19What to Do After Tuesday
Uri Zehavi52:19
Right. And for people in this audience who care about Israel, after Tuesday, what's the single most useful thing they can do, in your view?
Joel Rayburn52:29
Uh, look, look, I, uh, it's, uh, so, good question. Although I think, so let me, I think, what, I can't speak, I can't answer for your audience. Uh, let me answer for myself though. Um, I mean, what I intend to do is, is, is to, is to try to contribute to, uh, understanding of the strategic environment in the Middle East and the role that Israel plays in it. And the, and the, and the value, the necessity right now, the imperative that the US-Israel relationship remains, uh, strong and that, uh, and, and that it's, it's supported. I think many times, you know, a lot of, uh, a lot of what I see in part, part of it's my old, I was an intelligence officer.
So part of it's my own intelligence mind, but it's, there's very clear that, that some of the pressure, uh, coming in social media and media platforms, uh, uh, um, that's attacking, criticizing, trying to undermine the US-Israel, the strength of the US-Israel relationship. Some of that is coming from foreign, uh, actors that have a strategic interest in trying to pressure the, that, that, that, in trying to pressure our alliance for their own ends. And so I, I think we, that needs to be explored as well. And where they're, and, and, and where it comes out into the open, it needs to be called out, uh, as, as the signs of what is essentially an information operation, an influence operation.
53:54The Last Word: The US-Israel Tech Alliance
And last word, is there anything we didn't ask tonight that you wish we had?
Joel Rayburn54:01
Well, look, I, yeah, I, I think one of the, one of the big aspects, you know, for somebody like me who comes from national security world and military world, the relationship with Israel, the relations, the CENTCOM Israel relationship, you know, makes strategic sense. And from my familiarity with Israel, when I go there, and, and just sort of keep track of, of what's happening there, Israel is booming. And Israel, Israel has one of the most vibrant, uh, growing economies, not just in that region, but globally. And Israel is, uh, such a technological innovator. It's, it's, it's almost, you know, it's, it's like the tech, it's a country that's the tech incubator.
So it's a real analog, um, to, to Silicon Valley. So there's a lot of innovation that's happening in Israel. A lot of times there are concepts that are developed and begun to be fielded in Silicon Valley that make their way over to Israel and then get really creative. And it's almost like then it, it bounces back to us with even more enhancement in a way that benefits, that benefits us. So the tech, the, the US Israel technological alliance, if you will, I think in the future is going to be even more important than the US Israel military alliance. So, so, so, so much of the aspect, so, so much of the relationship has been about, well, will Israel be buying US munitions?
Will the US be financing the buying of Israel's buying of US munitions? When in reality, I think the future of it is a technological alliance, uh, between the US as the US tech sector and Israel as startup nation, if you will.
55:40Closing
Uri Zehavi55:40
Thank you, Joel. Um, that's all the time we have this evening. Really appreciate you stepping in to carry the whole hour on your own, doing it with a real generosity and a lot of knowledge. We're very grateful. I'm sorry, tonight. That wasn't the conversation we had planned. Joel Rubin couldn't get, uh, on due to some technical difficulties. We'll have him back for a full conversation on his own. So you'll hear both sides. Um, and one more time. So it is clear the Atlanta Israel Coalition is non-partisan. We don't endorse or oppose any candidate or party and our guests speak for themselves. We've recorded the chat tonight and it will go out as a recording.
So if you missed the start or want to share it, you'll have it. If tonight was your first time with us, AIC is a grassroots non-partisan group. We take on antisemitism here. And when Israel needs help, we go. We run on our members. You can learn more at AtlantaIsrael.org. And it's what keeps evenings like this free. Next Thursday, November 5th at noon, Guy Haran joins us on Israel Up Close to talk about Israeli wine. Bring a glass and a question. Thank you for all for being here and for caring about this. Good night.
Give
Your gift funds the work.
Community briefings, advocacy training, humanitarian missions to Israel, and the Kosher Duck Revolution, with specifics on every tier.
- $36Double chaiThe materials behind a community briefing.Give $36
- $180Advocacy training for a group of community members.Give $180
- $750Toward licensed security at a community event.Give $750
Gifts are tax-deductible to the extent allowed by law.

